![Barclays-Premier-League-t-001](https://ryangcamp.wordpress.com/wp-content/uploads/2012/02/barclays-premier-league-t-001.jpeg?w=460&h=276)
This is my response to a great comment left to me by Vosk, who brought up some interesting points in my previous article about improving the premier league. From all the hate I got from everyone in Europe, and all the love I got from everyone in the US, this is clearly just a cultural sports thing. Anyways, If you havent read it or Vosk’s comment please do so here.
**In case you are a moron, Vosk’s quotes are bolded, and my responses follow
There is a reason the league is 38 games, the best team over the season wins, why would anyone in the world want a shower of clowns like newcastle winning the league on playoffs?????
As far as the regular season goes, I completely agree. The best team in the regular season should win the regular season.Thats an honor within itself. But that is only the REGULAR season. What about the postseason?? Every other great team sport in the world that matters has a post season. In fact football’s (soccer) most prestigious events have a playoff system (Both the Champs League and the World Cup). Winning in the playoffs is what really makes teams legendary. When the pressure is on, and the whole world is watching the real champs will step up.
In the Premier league no game matters more than any other. That is a statistical fact. 3 points is always 3 points. Hypothetically if City in a season happened to never beat a top 5 the whole year, yet beat up on the crap teams and still had the most points, they would be champs. Is that fair? Maybe. But there could be many reasons such as injuries, bad calls, manager changes, etc that accounted for this.Also, teams evolve and change though the year. This means the best team at the end of the year might not win the title because they were still learning to play together at the start. Being a champion is about who is left standing at the end of the year, otherwise the season would only be 4 games long. Shouldn’t teams have to prove themselves in the playoffs, at the end of the year, where sports are always at their best?
The regular season winner would certainly be rewarded by being the No. 1 seed. They would get a first round buy, and would then play the lowest seed left. But being good in the regular season and being great when it matters is a different story. Take your team United this year. They have been awful this year when they are in big games that actually matter (or have the pressure of elimination on them) such as their displays in the Champions League debacles against Benfica and Basel, in elimination games in both the FA cup and Carling Cups, and even against Ajax in the Europa league last night. Do you really get the feeling this is a championship worthy United team? And yet they may very well be champs in a few months. I dont know. Im not saying they are or aren’t. Yet they could win the title by one point because City draws the last game of the year. If there were a playoff system, how unbelievable would that be! If you make it through the gauntlet of those games then there is no question you would be champs ans deserve every bit of credit. Think of it reversed as well. Say you lose 3 games here in a row. You are out of the title race. City could at the end of the year, limp into a 1 point margin and win the league. Yet with Furgy as your manager, United may very well come into their own and be hands down the best team at the end of the year. But it wouldn’t matter. I would hate to see that.
Secondly, opening the the league up a little is a GREAT thing. I know you probably hate it because you are a United fan (I have nothing against United fans for the record) and love seeing them win title after title, but you know that being in contention is really about the money. Money is the only thing that realistically gives a team any shot whatsoever. And for the record im not saying United only wins because of money. Im saying to be in contention to win, you have to have money. That eliminates 75% of the league. Why not just make the league 6 teams then? If you know nobody else has a shot then why even let them play? I hate hearing teams say “yeah finishing 11th was an amazing year for us”. You play to win the game. Not finish 11th place. Thats garbage. You shouldnt be playing sports if you want to finish 11th. Go play the guitar or something, because clearly you arent even worthy enough to win at any sport. With playoff berths available at the 5 and 6 spots there is certainly a chance for any team to go on a great run and make it into the playoffs.
buys/first picks’ are literally the worst ideas iv ever heard
I never once mentioned first picks. Or a draft. Yet you wrote a whole Paragraph on it? Not sure where that came from? I know thats unrealistic.
You cannot devalue the FA cup like you have here, im sure you wouldnt make this comment if you have watched enough of those games, totenham’s game at the weekend was a perfect example of the FA cup, im sure any player whose played in england will tell you they would love an FA winners medal.
My idea doesnt de-value the FA cup. It increases its value, does it not? Doesnt increasing the stakes make it more valueable for a team to win? This is just commense sense. Increase the reward and you increase the value. But this would only work if you have the playoff scenarios. I agree it does ruin the FA cup without a playoff system. And for the record, I watched that Tottenham game over the weekend. A womens football match would have been more entertaining.
Tottenham sure didnt look like a team who cared. And thats because they probably didnt. And dont go telling me Stevenage played an inspired game of football. If Spurs want a medal they should show it.
Lastly diving is part of the game, get used to it.
I get that. But what I’m saying is, it doesn’t have to be. Its only part of the game because we let it be part of the game. You are right, I like it when guys get fouled on purpose when they are being crafty and generally do get their legs clipped. I am only talking about video replay confirmed dives where no contact was made whatsoever. Its unfair guys get cards for no reason and games are decided on cheating. If you have at least one eye that can see and 10% of a brain then you could easily have retroactive fines based on replay, without any abuse of power or opening a can of worms on judgement calls.